
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travelers who want a small, members‑club atmosphere, waterfront views, and Cipriani dining in Lower Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a small members‑club–style luxury hotel in a restored Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal on the southern tip of Manhattan; read this if you want a polished, waterfront, clubby stay with Cipriani dining. The St. Regis New York is a classic Fifth Avenue grand luxury hotel with formal service and traditional St. Regis butler service; read this if you prefer Midtown shopping, museums, and a long-standing luxury hotel experience.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a small, members‑club atmosphere, waterfront views, and Cipriani dining in Lower Manhattan.

Best for travelers who want a grand, formal Midtown address with in‑room butler service and easy access to Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani if you value a small hotel with private club access, waterfront terraces and skyline/Brooklyn Bridge views, strong Cipriani food and live jazz, and event spaces in a historic landmark building.
When The St. Regis New York wins: choose The St. Regis for a traditional Fifth Avenue grand‑hotel experience, a wide range of room and suite types with included butler service on many room categories, and immediate proximity to Midtown shopping, MoMA, and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: both are polished 5‑star Manhattan hotels but they serve different priorities — Casa Cipriani for a members‑club, harbor‑facing escape in Lower Manhattan; The St. Regis for classic, formal Midtown luxury and easy access to central Manhattan sights.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Members‑club luxury, Beaux‑Arts building, intimate and curated. | Classic Fifth Avenue grand hotel, formal and traditional. |
| Location | Lower Manhattan, Battery Maritime Building, waterfront near Battery Park and ferry piers. | Midtown Manhattan on Two East 55th St, steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center. |
| Size (rooms) | 47 rooms and suites across six floors. | 238 guestrooms. |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome as hotel guests; primary guest must meet a minimum check‑in age (sources list 18–21); fifth‑floor club enforces club rules. | All ages welcome (not adults‑only). |
| Pools | Rooftop pool for the members' club reported in recent press; status has varied across sources. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues (The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café, Living Room). | 2 restaurants and 1 bar/lounge listed; room service (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | Casa Cipriani Wellness / The Spa at Casa Cipriani with steam room, sauna, cryotherapy, treatments and 24‑hour key‑card fitness access. | Spa services and 24‑hour fitness facilities listed; additional spa details not published in supplier listing. |
| Signature service | Private‑club access and Cipriani hospitality across food and club spaces. | Butler service included with many room and suite types. |
| Event space | About 20,000 sq ft of landmarked event space (Great Hall, Loggia, multiple concourses) for up to 1,500+ guests. | Conference space of 3,944 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms. |
| Nearby highlights | Battery Park, Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island ferries, Governors Island, Wall Street, South Street Seaport. | 5th Avenue shopping, Rockefeller Center, MoMA, Central Park, Radio City Music Hall. |
Casa Cipriani sits in the landmark Battery Maritime Building at the southern tip of Manhattan with direct access to harbor ferries and waterfront parks.
Choose Casa Cipriani for waterfront access and Lower Manhattan points of interest.
The St. Regis New York is on East 55th Street, immediately adjacent to Fifth Avenue shopping and Midtown cultural attractions.
Choose The St. Regis for Midtown convenience and Fifth Avenue proximity.
Casa Cipriani is intentionally small with 47 individually designed rooms and suites by Thierry Despont, many with river or bridge views.
Choose Casa Cipriani if you want fewer rooms, distinctive interiors, and water views.
The St. Regis offers a broad range of classic rooms and suites (many with included butler service) suited to a variety of needs.
Choose The St. Regis for a wider choice of room sizes and formal butler service.
Casa Cipriani centers on Cipriani cuisine across several member‑and‑guest venues, plus a Jazz Café with nightly music.
Choose Casa Cipriani for Cipriani dining, terraces and a supper‑club jazz atmosphere.
The St. Regis lists two restaurants and a bar/lounge with room service available (limited hours); dining is traditional hotel fare with service staff support.
Choose The St. Regis if you want classic hotel dining with easy Midtown access to many external restaurants.
Casa Cipriani’s member club and recent press highlight rooftop leisure features and wellness facilities tied to the club.
Casa Cipriani’s signature is its clubby waterfront amenities and spa; verify current pool access and hours before arrival.
The St. Regis’s highlights are service features and centrality rather than waterfront leisure facilities.
The St. Regis is strongest for formal service and Midtown location rather than a waterfront or rooftop leisure focus.
Casa Cipriani offers an in‑house spa and a live‑music Jazz Café, blending wellness and evening entertainment.
Choose Casa Cipriani for spa treatments plus a jazz supper‑club scene in the evenings.
The St. Regis provides salon services, 24‑hour fitness, and classic late‑night hotel support; nightlife is mostly found outside in Midtown.
Choose The St. Regis if you want in‑house grooming services and easy access to Midtown nightlife options.

Casa Cipriani — direct waterfront location near Battery Park and ferry terminals, with many rooms and terraces facing the East River and Brooklyn Bridge.

The St. Regis — steps from Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and MoMA, ideal for museum‑and‑shopping‑focused itineraries.

Casa Cipriani — a private members' club paired with a 47‑room hotel that reserves club spaces for members and guests.

The St. Regis — formal, historic St. Regis service with many room categories offering butler service.
Casa Cipriani is the better choice for Lower Manhattan, with immediate access to Battery Park, ferry piers and Wall Street.
Yes — many St. Regis room and suite categories explicitly list butler service as included.
Casa Cipriani operates as a members' club combined with a hotel; hotel guests have access to club spaces and some spa services can be booked by non‑members, but many dining and club areas are reserved for members and registered guests.
Casa Cipriani offers very large landmarked event spaces (about 20,000 sq ft, including the Great Hall and Loggia) compared with The St. Regis’s listed conference space (3,944 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms).
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·