
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travelers who prioritize a private‑club experience, waterfront views, and event/banquet space in a landmarked building.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a small, members‑club–style luxury hotel inside the restored Battery Maritime Building on the southern tip of Manhattan—best for travelers who want a clubby, harborfront stay with Cipriani dining and event spaces. The Dominick is a SoHo luxury high‑rise with a larger room inventory and a seasonal outdoor pool—read this if you’re weighing a downtown high‑rise with more public hotel amenities against a private‑club hotel with waterfront character.
Updated · about 1.7 km apart

Best for travelers who prioritize a private‑club experience, waterfront views, and event/banquet space in a landmarked building.

Best for guests who want a larger downtown hotel with a full roster of public amenities (outdoor seasonal pool, larger spa and meeting capacity).
Casa Cipriani New York wins when you want a members‑club atmosphere, Cipriani food and drink, waterfront terraces, and a small number of rooms with personalized service—also the better pick for weddings and large private events in a landmark setting.
The Dominick wins when you prefer a conventional luxury hotel with many room choices, a year‑round program of on‑site amenities including a seasonal outdoor pool, and easier walkability to SoHo/NYU/Bleecker Street shopping and restaurants.
Bottom line: choose Casa Cipriani for clubby, waterfront luxury and landmark character; choose The Dominick for a larger, service‑rich SoHo high‑rise with a rooftop/seasonal pool and more conventional hotel infrastructure.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | The Dominick |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Members‑club, intimate, historic Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal | Contemporary SoHo luxury high‑rise, more public hotel feel |
| Location | Lower Manhattan waterfront at 10 South St near Battery Park, ferries and Wall Street | SoHo/Prince Street area at 246 Spring St, steps from Bleecker and NYU |
| Size (rooms) | 47 rooms and suites | 391 rooms and suites |
| Building type / setting | Landmarked Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal (Battery Maritime Building) | Modern high‑rise hotel |
| Pools | Members' rooftop pool referenced in recent press; earlier sources said no guest pool (status varied) | Outdoor seasonal pool (rooftop); open seasonally (May–Sept) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues: The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café (hotel guests and members) | On‑site restaurant and bar/lounge with room service (name not published) |
| Spa & wellness | Casa Cipriani Wellness / The Spa: sauna, steam, cryotherapy, red‑light sauna, treatments and 24‑hour key‑card fitness access | Full‑service spa, sauna, steam room, 24‑hour fitness center and treatments |
| Event space / meetings | About 20,000 sq ft of landmark event space (Great Hall, Loggia) with capacities up to ~1,500 seated | Ballroom and banquet/meeting facilities (meeting rooms and banquet hall listed) |
| Accessibility & family policy | Not an adults‑only property; club spaces have age/entry rules; minimum check‑in age varies by listing (confirm with hotel) | Not adults‑only; standard hotel policies with minimum check‑in age 21 listed in supplier notes |
| Nearby highlights | Steps to Battery Park, Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island ferries, Governors Island departures | Within walking distance of Washington Square Park, NYU, Bleecker Street and SoHo shopping |
Casa Cipriani sits inside the landmark Battery Maritime Building at Manhattan’s southern tip, with direct access to harbor ferries and Battery Park.
Choose Casa Cipriani for direct waterfront access and proximity to downtown waterfront attractions.
The Dominick is located in SoHo, placing you close to Bleecker Street, Washington Square Park, and SoHo shopping.
Choose The Dominick if you want to be based in SoHo and close to downtown shopping and dining.
Casa Cipriani offers 47 rooms and suites with Thierry Despont interiors, many with river or bridge views and a small‑hotel feel.
Expect fewer rooms and a curated, club‑style stay at Casa Cipriani.
The Dominick operates on a much larger scale with 391 air‑conditioned rooms and many view options and suite configurations.
The Dominick offers many room types and views, useful if you need specific accessibility or connecting room arrangements.
Casa Cipriani pairs hotel stays with Cipriani dining across several club venues for a consistent culinary identity.
If Cipriani cuisine, live jazz and waterfront terraces matter, Casa Cipriani is the clearer fit.
The Dominick provides an on‑site restaurant and bar with room service; the supplier listing confirms food service but does not publish the restaurant name in the supplied facts.
Expect a conventional hotel dining setup at The Dominick with poolside and in‑house options.
Casa Cipriani’s pool situation is mixed in public sources: earlier reports said no guest pool, while recent press and member listings describe a members' rooftop pool.
Pool availability at Casa Cipriani may depend on club access and evolving openings; confirm current access before booking.
The Dominick lists an outdoor seasonal pool and poolside bar among its public amenities.
Choose The Dominick if a clearly marketed outdoor seasonal pool is important to your stay.
Casa Cipriani offers a branded spa and wellness program plus club nightlife focused on the Jazz Café and club lounges.
Wellness and nightlife at Casa Cipriani are integrated with the private‑club model and Cipriani programming.
The Dominick’s wellness offerings include a full‑service spa, sauna/steam and a 24‑hour fitness center.
The Dominick provides standard full‑service hotel spa facilities and leisure options for a broader guest base.

Casa Cipriani — immediate access to ferries, Battery Park, and rooms with East River/Brooklyn Bridge views.

The Dominick — clearly listed outdoor seasonal pool, poolside bar, and many public hotel amenities.

Casa Cipriani — extensive landmarked event spaces including the Great Hall and Loggia with large capacities.

The Dominick — 391 rooms with many view and suite options, helpful for larger groups or specific room needs.
Casa Cipriani is waterfront at the Battery Maritime Building with terraces and ferry access; The Dominick is inland in SoHo.
Sources vary: older listings said no guest pool, recent press and member reporting describe a members’ rooftop pool. Confirm current guest access with the hotel before booking.
The Dominick has a larger inventory and a conventional hotel amenity set (seasonal outdoor pool, full‑service spa, larger meeting facilities). Casa Cipriani focuses on club spaces, Cipriani dining and landmark event venues.
Casa Cipriani operates as a private members’ club paired with a hotel; hotel guests have access to club facilities. The Dominick is a standard luxury hotel open to the public.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·