
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travelers who want a private‑club atmosphere, Cipriani dining and landmark waterfront character in Lower Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a 47-room members’ club and luxury hotel in a restored Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal at the southern tip of Manhattan; read this if you value club-style Cipriani dining, waterfront terraces, and event spaces. Four Seasons Hotel New York is an internationally recognized Midtown ultra‑luxury hotel with larger inventory and classic Midtown addresses; read this if you want Midtown refinement, Central Park proximity, and a full‑service luxury hotel experience.
Updated · about 7 km apart

Best for travelers who want a private‑club atmosphere, Cipriani dining and landmark waterfront character in Lower Manhattan.

Best for travelers who want Midtown location, classic Four Seasons service, and a larger selection of suite types near Central Park and Fifth Avenue.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani for the clubby Cipriani restaurants and lounges, landmark Beaux‑Arts setting at the Battery Maritime Building, and a small number of highly designed rooms where terrace and East River/Brooklyn Bridge views matter. It’s the better pick for intimate events and waterfront access to ferries.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: pick Four Seasons for a traditional Midtown luxury stay with many room and suite configurations (including Central Park and city-view suites), more meeting space and standard full‑service hotel facilities geared toward business and family travel. It’s the safer choice for those who want a central Midtown base near 5th Avenue and the Park.
Bottom line: Casa Cipriani is a specialized, small‑scale hotel + private club best for guests prioritizing Cipriani’s food, club spaces and Lower Manhattan waterfront character. Four Seasons is a large, mainstream ultra‑luxury Midtown hotel that offers breadth of rooms and conventional full‑service amenities for travelers who want a Midtown address.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Private‑club luxury, Cipriani social spaces, historic ferry terminal character | Classic international ultra‑luxury Midtown hotel with formal service |
| Location | Lower Manhattan; Battery Maritime Building on South Street near Battery Park and ferry piers | Midtown Manhattan; 57 E 57th Street near 5th Avenue and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 47 rooms and suites | 368 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Typical guestage/policy | Hotel guests + private‑club members; primary guest minimum check‑in age (varies by source) | All ages; standard Four Seasons family‑friendly policies (one child 17 or younger stays free per listing) |
| Pools / rooftop pool | Members' rooftop pool referenced in recent press but status varies by source | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues: The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café, Living Room, terraces (hotel guests and members) | The Garden Restaurant, bar/lounge, 24‑hour room service (per supplier listing) |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Casa Cipriani with sauna, steam room, cryotherapy, red light sauna, treatments and 24‑hour fitness access | 24‑hour fitness facilities; spa details not published in supplier listing |
| Event & meeting space | About 20,000 sq ft of event space (Great Hall, Loggia, multiple suites) for up to 1,500 seated/2,500 standing | Conference center and meeting rooms totaling about 12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²) per supplier listing |
| Known for | Cipriani dining and private‑club atmosphere inside a landmark Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal | Midtown prestige, proximity to 5th Avenue and Central Park, longstanding Four Seasons service |
| Nearby highlights | Battery Park, Staten Island ferry, Governors Island ferries, Wall Street, South Street Seaport | 5th Avenue, Central Park, Rockefeller Center, MoMA, Carnegie Hall (within short walk) |
Casa Cipriani sits in the landmark Battery Maritime Building at the southern tip of Manhattan, overlooking the East River and Brooklyn Bridge.
Choose Casa Cipriani if you want waterfront access, nearby ferry excursions, and Lower Manhattan sightseeing.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is on East 57th Street near 5th Avenue and Central Park, placing you in Midtown shopping, museums and theaters.
Choose Four Seasons if you want a Midtown base close to Central Park and Fifth Avenue.
Casa Cipriani has 47 rooms and suites designed by Thierry Despont, many with river or bridge views and a compact, boutique scale.
Expect individually styled rooms and a small property scale that emphasizes design and views.
Four Seasons Hotel New York provides 368 individually decorated guestrooms and a wide range of suite layouts including Central Park and city‑view options.
Expect many room and suite choices with the predictable amenities of a full‑service luxury hotel.
Casa Cipriani’s food and drink is central: multiple Cipriani venues operate as club and hotel spaces.
Choose Casa Cipriani if Cipriani restaurants, terraces and a jazz supper‑club matter to your stay.
Four Seasons’ supplier listing highlights The Garden Restaurant and 24‑hour room service plus a bar/lounge.
Pick Four Seasons if you prefer a classic single‑hotel fine dining venue with around‑the‑clock room service.
Casa Cipriani’s club facilities (fifth‑floor club and terraces) are central; reporting on a rooftop pool is mixed across sources.
Club spaces and event venues are primary; confirm rooftop pool status directly with the hotel before booking.
Four Seasons’ supplier listing emphasizes full‑service hotel amenities such as conference space and 24‑hour fitness facilities.
Four Seasons offers wide meeting and fitness facilities; confirm pool or spa specifics with the property if critical.
Casa Cipriani combines spa services and a strong nightlife component through its Jazz Café and club lounges.
Pick Casa Cipriani when you want integrated spa treatments plus late‑night jazz and club atmospheres in one place.
Four Seasons lists fitness facilities and some family‑friendly services; the supplier listing highlights business and reception amenities.
Choose Four Seasons for dependable fitness and business services; check directly for spa and evening entertainment details.

Casa Cipriani — steps from Battery Park, the Staten Island ferry and Governors Island departures, with river views and terraces.

Four Seasons — immediate access to 5th Avenue, Central Park and Midtown cultural institutions.

Casa Cipriani — a members’ club with exclusive fifth‑floor spaces, Cipriani dining and a small hotel footprint.

Four Seasons — 368 guestrooms and numerous suite types for travelers who want variety and larger suites.
Casa Cipriani is closer to Battery Park and ferry departures and offers river/harbor views; it’s the more convenient base for Liberty/Ellis Island trips.
Dining venues are primarily for hotel guests and club members; hotel guests have access but non‑members should check reservation policies in advance.
Four Seasons has many more guestrooms (368) and substantial conference space per its supplier listing. Casa Cipriani focuses on a smaller, high‑design room inventory and large landmark event halls for special events.
Casa Cipriani is an all‑ages property per its policies, but the primary booking guest must meet the property’s minimum check‑in age (sources vary between 18 and 21); specific club areas restrict under‑21s after certain hours.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·