
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travelers who want a private‑club setting, intimate size, and waterfront terraces with Cipriani cuisine.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a small, members‑club–paired luxury hotel in a restored Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal at Lower Manhattan’s waterfront; read this if you want a private‑club atmosphere, waterfront terraces, and Cipriani dining. The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York is a long‑established Fifth Avenue luxury property beside Central Park; read this if you want classic Upper East Side service, park views, and a landmark address.
Updated · about 5 km apart

Best for travelers who want a private‑club setting, intimate size, and waterfront terraces with Cipriani cuisine.

Best for travelers seeking classic Fifth Avenue luxury, direct access to Central Park, and a large, traditional hotel experience.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani for a small, private‑club feel, strong Cipriani food and beverage offerings, and a downtown waterfront location that’s convenient for Battery Park, Governors Island and harbor ferries.
When The Pierre wins: choose The Pierre for a landmark Fifth Avenue address beside Central Park, a broad range of room types and suites, and traditional full‑service hotel amenities that suit sightseeing around Midtown and the Upper East Side.
Bottom line: these are different experiences—Casa Cipriani is a boutique, club‑infused waterfront hotel in Lower Manhattan; The Pierre is a large, historic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel by Central Park. Pick Casa for intimacy and club access, The Pierre for classic Park‑side luxury and a central Midtown/Upper East Side base.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Private members' club + small luxury hotel in a restored ferry terminal; intimate, curated service | Historic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with traditional full‑service amenities and formal service |
| Location | 10 South St — Lower Manhattan waterfront, steps from Battery Park and ferry piers | 2 E 61st St — Fifth Avenue beside Central Park, near Bergdorf Goodman |
| Size (rooms) | 47 rooms and suites | 189 rooms and suites |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome as guests; minimum check‑in age listed as 18–21 depending on source (confirm with hotel) | All ages welcome (not adults‑only) |
| Pools | Conflicting reports about a rooftop/members' pool; current public status not consistently published | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues: The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café, Living Room and terraces | Perrine (fine dining) plus a bar/lounge and 24‑hour room service (per supplier listing) |
| Spa & wellness | Casa Cipriani Wellness / The Spa at Casa Cipriani with steam room, sauna, cryotherapy, treatments and 24‑hour keycard fitness access | Spa services on site and a 24‑hour health club listed among amenities |
| Known for | Members' club atmosphere, Cipriani dining, landmarked Beaux‑Arts building and waterfront views | Landmark Fifth Avenue address, park views and long‑standing luxury hotel reputation |
| Event space | Large event capacity across multiple rooms (about 20,000 sq ft; Great Hall, Loggia, concourses) | Conference space and meeting rooms (supplier lists conference/meeting facilities) |
| Accessibility & family notes | Club areas limited to guests and members; confirm age/club access policies with the property | Wheelchair‑accessible features and multilingual staff listed; standard full‑service hotel accessibility offerings |
Casa Cipriani sits in the restored Battery Maritime Building at Manhattan’s southern tip, with immediate harbor and ferry access.
Choose Casa Cipriani for waterfront access and quick harbor ferry connections.
The Pierre faces Central Park on Fifth Avenue, placing you in the Upper East Side close to museums and Midtown shopping.
Choose The Pierre for parkside stays and Midtown/Upper East Side sightseeing.
Casa Cipriani has 47 rooms and suites with Thierry Despont interiors and several room types offering river or city views.
Casa Cipriani is for travelers who prefer a small, design‑forward room inventory and waterfront outlooks.
The Pierre offers a broad roster of room types and suites—from Deluxe rooms to Presidential suites—suiting varied needs.
The Pierre is the pick if you want many room and suite options, including large signature suites.
Casa Cipriani’s food and drink focus is Cipriani—multiple on‑site venues with terrace and jazz options.
Pick Casa Cipriani for consistent Cipriani dining and multiple club venues with river views.
The Pierre offers classic hotel dining with a noted fine‑dining French venue and a bar/lounge.
Choose The Pierre for a classic, park‑side hotel dining experience and formal restaurant options.
Casa Cipriani emphasizes club wellness and terraces; public reporting on pool access is mixed.
Plan around the spa and fitness offerings; confirm the rooftop/members' pool status with the hotel before booking.
The Pierre lists spa services and a 24‑hour health club among featured amenities; supplier listing does not publish a pool.
The Pierre provides full‑service wellness and fitness; if an on‑site pool matters, confirm directly with the property.
Casa Cipriani pairs a wellness program with club nightlife—live jazz, late‑night dining and members' lounges.
Casa Cipriani is for guests who want club‑style nightlife with integrated wellness services.
The Pierre provides traditional hotel nightlife and spa services suitable for parkside evenings and formal dining.
Choose The Pierre if you prefer classic hotel evenings and parkside leisure with formal dining.

Casa Cipriani — members' club areas, club dining and club terraces for guests and members.

The Pierre — immediate Fifth Avenue location beside Central Park and close to Midtown attractions.

The Pierre — wide range of room types and multiple grand and presidential suites.

Casa Cipriani — multiple Cipriani venues, terraces and East River/Brooklyn Bridge outlooks.
Casa Cipriani is much closer to Battery Park, ferries to the Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island and the South Street Seaport.
The Pierre is located on Fifth Avenue adjacent to Central Park, making it the better choice for park access and Upper East Side museums.
Neither property is all‑inclusive; dining and club access policies vary—Casa Cipriani’s club spaces are for guests and members and some venues may have member restrictions.
Public reporting is inconsistent; contact Casa Cipriani directly to confirm current pool availability and whether it’s limited to members.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·