
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travelers who prioritize a waterfront address, historic Beaux‑Arts architecture, Cipriani restaurants, and intimate club-style service.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a small luxury hotel and private members' club inside a restored Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal on the southern tip of Manhattan; it suits travelers who want waterfront views, Cipriani dining, and landmark character. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a high‑rise luxury hotel at Columbus Circle with large spa and skyline views; it suits travelers who want Central Park/Hudson River outlooks, bigger facilities, and an established global brand.
Updated

Best for travelers who prioritize a waterfront address, historic Beaux‑Arts architecture, Cipriani restaurants, and intimate club-style service.

Best for travelers who want Midtown convenience, sweeping skyline or park views, a large full-service spa and indoor pool, and the consistency of a major luxury brand.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani for a small, intimate property with dramatic East River/Brooklyn Bridge sightlines, Cipriani dining and private club spaces in a landmarked building. It’s the stronger pick for wedding and event clients who want a landmark setting or for guests prioritizing waterfront terraces and live jazz.
When Mandarin Oriental, New York wins: pick the Mandarin Oriental for a larger hotel with more rooms, an established full‑service spa, an indoor pool, and immediate access to Columbus Circle and Central Park. It’s the better option for travelers who want a full roster of hotel services, meeting facilities, and consistent luxury‑brand standards.
Bottom line: Casa Cipriani is a boutique, design- and dining-forward choice on the harbor with private‑club access and landmark character; Mandarin Oriental is a classic high-rise luxury property anchored in Midtown with larger wellness and service facilities. Your choice depends on whether you prefer historic waterfront intimacy (Casa) or Midtown scale and spa/pool amenities (Mandarin).
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Beaux‑Arts ferry terminal converted into a members' club + hotel; intimate and design‑forward. | Contemporary high‑rise luxury hotel with polished, skyline-facing rooms and full hotel services. |
| Location | 10 South St; Lower Manhattan, steps from Battery Park, Staten Island/Liberty ferries and South Street Seaport. | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street; adjacent to Columbus Circle and Central Park. |
| Size (rooms) | 47 guestrooms and suites across six floors. | 244 guestrooms (supplier listing). |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must meet minimum check‑in age (sources differ 18 vs 21). | All ages welcome; not an adults‑only property (supplier listing). |
| Pools | Rooftop pool reported as a members'‑club feature in recent coverage; public guest access and status vary by report. | Indoor pool (1) available as part of full wellness offerings. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues for members and hotel guests: The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café, Living Room. | MO Lounge, 24‑hour room service, two bars/lounges (supplier listing: number of restaurants 1, number of bars/lounges 2). |
| Spa / wellness | Casa Cipriani Wellness / The Spa at Casa Cipriani with steam room, sauna, cryotherapy, IV therapy, treatment rooms and a 24‑hour key‑card fitness center. | Full‑service spa with massages, facials, body treatments, fitness facilities, sauna and indoor pool. |
| Known for | Waterfront terraces and views of Brooklyn Bridge, East River and Statue of Liberty; Cipriani dining and landmark event spaces. | Skyline and park views from high floors, established Mandarin Oriental service and a substantial spa program. |
| Event space | Extensive: ~20,000 sq ft of event space including the Great Hall and Loggia; large capacity for weddings and galas. | Meeting and event facilities (supplier listing includes meeting/banquet spaces and ballroom). |
| Typical guest | Guests seeking a members'‑club atmosphere, Cipriani dining, landmark architecture and waterfront views. | Guests wanting Midtown access, consistent brand standards, large spa and indoor pool, and skyline/Central Park views. |
Casa Cipriani sits inside the landmark Battery Maritime Building at the southern tip of Manhattan, overlooking New York Harbor.
Choose Casa Cipriani if you want Lower Manhattan waterfront access and historic surroundings.
Mandarin Oriental is a high‑rise hotel at Columbus Circle, bordering Central Park and Midtown attractions.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for Midtown convenience and quick access to Central Park and cultural institutions.
Casa Cipriani operates 47 rooms and suites with interiors by Thierry Despont and maritime-inspired details.
Choose Casa Cipriani for fewer rooms, more character and waterfront outlooks.
Mandarin Oriental offers a much larger room inventory (244 guestrooms) with Hudson River or Central Park sightlines depending on room type.
Choose Mandarin Oriental if you want a larger choice of room types and high‑level skyline or park views.
Casa Cipriani centers its food and drink around Cipriani restaurants and historic dining rooms, reserved for guests and members.
Choose Casa Cipriani for Cipriani's Italian menus, live jazz and waterfront terraces.
Mandarin Oriental offers MO Lounge and bar/room‑service options, with standard luxury hotel dining and two bars/lounges listed.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for reliable hotel dining options, lounge settings and full room service.
Casa Cipriani's pool situation is mixed in public sources: early reviews said no pool, while recent coverage describes a rooftop pool as a members' club feature.
Pool availability at Casa Cipriani depends on current members' club operations; verify access in advance.
Mandarin Oriental's supplier listing includes one indoor pool as part of its wellness/recreation facilities.
Choose Mandarin Oriental if a hotel pool and integrated spa facilities are priorities.
Casa Cipriani provides a full wellness program under Casa Cipriani Wellness, plus live music and late‑night dining in the Jazz Café and lounges.
Choose Casa Cipriani for a wellness program combined with a members'‑club nightlife and late‑night jazz.
Mandarin Oriental offers a substantial spa program, sauna, fitness facilities and a quieter, upscale bar/lounge scene.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for a larger, hotel‑scale spa and wellness program and calm lounge evenings.

Casa Cipriani — landmark Battery Maritime Building, terraces and river/bridge views.

Mandarin Oriental — full‑service spa and an indoor pool as listed in supplier amenities.

Casa Cipriani — multiple Cipriani venues and extensive landmark event spaces like the Great Hall and Loggia.

Mandarin Oriental — sits at Columbus Circle with direct access to Central Park and Midtown cultural sites.
Casa Cipriani. It’s steps from Battery Park, the Staten Island and Statue of Liberty/Liberty Island ferry departures, and South Street Seaport.
Mandarin Oriental lists an indoor pool as a hotel amenity. Casa Cipriani’s pool was reported as a rooftop members'‑club feature in recent coverage, but earlier sources listed no pool—confirm access before booking.
Both properties accept guests of all ages; Casa Cipriani requires the primary guest to meet a minimum check‑in age (sources vary between 18 and 21), and Mandarin Oriental is not adults‑only per supplier data.
Casa Cipriani — extensive landmark event spaces including the Great Hall and Loggia make it a standout for large weddings and gala events.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·