
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travelers who want a private‑club atmosphere, formal Cipriani dining, and a landmark waterfront setting.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a members-only private club paired with a small luxury hotel in the restored Battery Maritime Building, best for travelers who want a waterfront, club-driven experience and formal Cipriani dining. The New York EDITION is a larger, design-forward lifestyle hotel by Madison Square Park, for travelers who prefer stylish city-center accommodations with a social scene and accessible Flatiron location.
Updated · about 4.5 km apart

Best for travelers who want a private‑club atmosphere, formal Cipriani dining, and a landmark waterfront setting.

Best for travelers who want a centrally located, design-led luxury hotel near Madison Square Park and Flatiron attractions.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani if you want an intimate, club-driven stay, prioritized access to Cipriani restaurants and lounges, historic Beaux‑Arts architecture, and direct proximity to Battery Park, ferry services, and New York Harbor views.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick The New York EDITION if you prefer a larger, centrally located luxury hotel with a strong lifestyle identity near Madison Square Park, easy access to Flatiron and Midtown, more meeting space and conventional hotel services.
Bottom line: Casa Cipriani is a small, members‑club hotel focused on waterfront character, Cipriani food and private‑club spaces; The New York EDITION is a five‑star lifestyle hotel in the Flatiron area that suits travelers who want stylish, social city lodging with more rooms and conventional hotel amenities.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Private members' club + small luxury hotel in a landmark ferry terminal; formal, curated social spaces | Stylish, design-forward five-star lifestyle hotel with a social bar/restaurant scene |
| Location | Lower Manhattan waterfront at 10 South St near Battery Park and ferry terminals | Flatiron / Madison Square Park area at 5 Madison Avenue |
| Size (rooms) | 47 rooms and suites | 271 rooms and suites |
| Ages / access policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must meet minimum check-in age (sources vary 18–21); fifth-floor club restricts under‑21s after 5 PM | All ages welcome (adultsOnly: false) |
| Pools | Rooftop members' pool reported in recent coverage (membership / club context); public access and guest policy vary by report | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues (The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café, Living Room, terraces) reserved for guests and members | The Clocktower restaurant plus 2 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Casa Cipriani with eucalyptus steam room, cedar saunas, cryotherapy, treatments, and 24‑hour keycard fitness access | Spa services and spa treatment room(s) on site; fitness facilities and 24-hour fitness listed |
| Events & meeting space | About 20,000 sq ft of landmarked event space (Great Hall, Loggia, multiple suites) for large galas and weddings | Conference space ~2100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Known for | Historic Beaux‑Arts building, private‑club atmosphere, waterfront terraces and Cipriani dining | Design-led lifestyle brand in the Flatiron district with social dining and bars |
| Nearby highlights | Battery Park, Governors Island ferries, Wall Street, South Street Seaport | Madison Square Park, Flatiron Building, close to Empire State Building and Midtown attractions |
Casa Cipriani sits at the southern tip of Manhattan inside the landmark Battery Maritime Building with direct harbor access.
Choose Casa Cipriani for a waterfront, historic‑building experience and easy ferry access.
The New York EDITION is a five‑star lifestyle hotel a few steps from Madison Square Park in the Flatiron neighborhood.
Choose The New York EDITION for easy access to Flatiron and Midtown points of interest and a central Manhattan base.
Casa Cipriani has 47 rooms and suites with interiors by Thierry Despont and maritime-inspired details.
Casa Cipriani suits travelers who prefer a small, thoughtfully designed hotel with a club atmosphere.
The New York EDITION offers 271 rooms and suites across many room categories, mixing classic and contemporary design.
The New York EDITION is better if you want more room type variety and conventional luxury-hotel scale.
Casa Cipriani centers dining around Cipriani concepts and multiple member/guest venues.
Casa Cipriani is for diners seeking formal Cipriani service and club-style dining spaces with waterfront views.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant and two bars/lounges, aimed at a lifestyle hotel crowd.
The EDITION suits travelers who want on-site destination dining and hotel bars in the Flatiron neighborhood.
Casa Cipriani's members' amenities include recent reporting of a rooftop pool used in a club context.
Casa Cipriani's rooftop pool appears linked to the members' club and may not have uniform public access—confirm at booking.
The New York EDITION's supplier listing does not publish a guest pool.
The EDITION listing does not publish a pool—ask the hotel if a pool is a deciding factor.
Casa Cipriani offers a broad wellness program and nighttime music in club venues.
Casa Cipriani blends extensive wellness offerings with a structured, member-focused nightlife program.
The New York EDITION provides on-site spa services and 24-hour fitness alongside a hotel nightlife/dining program.
The EDITION is a solid option for standard hotel spa services and a conveniently located nightlife base in Flatiron.

Casa Cipriani — choose it for the members' club atmosphere, Cipriani dining options, and landmark waterfront setting.

The New York EDITION — ideal if you want to be steps from Madison Square Park, the Flatiron Building, and Midtown sights.

Casa Cipriani — large landmark event spaces (Great Hall, Loggia) and roughly 20,000 sq ft of event capacity.

The New York EDITION — more rooms, multiple meeting rooms, and conventional hotel services for typical business or leisure stays.
Casa Cipriani — it's steps from Battery Park and the Governors Island ferry departs from the Battery Maritime Building, making ferries and harbor excursions very convenient.
The New York EDITION — with 271 rooms and many suite categories it offers more variety and conventional hotel-scale services than Casa Cipriani's 47 rooms.
Casa Cipriani welcomes guests of all ages, but the primary guest must meet the property's minimum check-in age (sources vary 18–21); certain club areas restrict under‑21s after 5 PM.
The supplier listing for The New York EDITION does not publish a pool; confirm directly with the hotel if a pool is essential.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·