
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for a quiet, clubby Manhattan experience with waterfront views, Cipriani dining, and a strong members‑club atmosphere.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a small, members‑club style luxury hotel inside the restored Battery Maritime Building, best for travelers who want an intimate, waterside Manhattan stay with access to Cipriani dining and club spaces. Lotte New York Palace is a large, landmark Midtown luxury hotel near St. Patrick’s Cathedral and Rockefeller Center, best for travelers who want classic big‑city service, many room types, and large meeting/event space.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for a quiet, clubby Manhattan experience with waterfront views, Cipriani dining, and a strong members‑club atmosphere.

Best for a central Midtown base with many room configurations, extensive event space, and widely known New York visibility.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani if you want a small, members‑club atmosphere, waterfront and Brooklyn Bridge views, and access to Cipriani restaurants, live jazz, and a focused wellness program in Lower Manhattan.
When Lotte New York Palace wins: choose Lotte Palace if you need a large Midtown hotel with many room and suite types, on‑site meeting/conference facilities, a full spa and health‑club program, and an address steps from Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: both deliver recognized Manhattan luxury, but Casa Cipriani is intimate and club‑driven while Lotte New York Palace is a big, central Midtown property that suits larger groups and those prioritizing Midtown transit and sightlines.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | Lotte New York Palace |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Members‑club, intimate, Beaux‑Arts restored ferry terminal with waterfront terraces and live jazz | Large, landmark Midtown luxury hotel with formal public spaces and broad services |
| Location | Lower Manhattan at 10 South St, near Battery Park and ferry terminals | Midtown Manhattan at 455 Madison Ave, steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size | 47 rooms and suites | 909 guestrooms |
| Built / setting | Houses the 1909 Beaux‑Arts Battery Maritime Building (landmarked ferry terminal) | Large, historic Midtown hotel complex (well‑known city landmark hotel) |
| Pools | Members' rooftop pool reported in recent coverage; some sources say pool status varies — may be members‑club facility | Wheelchair-accessible pool listed in supplier amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Cipriani restaurants: The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café (hotel guests + members) | On‑site dining including Gold Room and a coffee shop/cafe; bar/lounge and room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Casa Cipriani Wellness / The Spa at Casa Cipriani with steam room, sauna, treatments, cryotherapy and 24‑hour key‑card fitness access | Full‑service spa, health club and steam room listed among amenities |
| Event space | About 20,000 sq ft event space (Great Hall, Loggia, multiple suites) for up to 1,500 seated | Conference center, meeting rooms and large ballrooms listed in amenities |
| Access to attractions | Walkable to Battery Park, Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island ferries and Governors Island; waterfront activities nearby | Walkable to 5th Avenue shops, Rockefeller Center, St. Patrick’s Cathedral, MoMA and Broadway |
| Internet & parking | Complimentary high‑speed Wi‑Fi; valet/covered parking for a surcharge (no free on‑site self parking) | Wired and wireless internet available for a surcharge; valet parking (surcharge) |
Casa Cipriani sits at the southern tip of Manhattan inside the Battery Maritime Building, oriented toward the harbor and ferry terminals.
Choose Casa Cipriani for waterfront access and proximity to Lower Manhattan attractions.
Lotte New York Palace sits in Midtown, close to Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and St. Patrick’s Cathedral.
Choose Lotte Palace when you want a Midtown base near major city sights and transit.
Casa Cipriani has 47 rooms and suites, designed by Thierry Despont with maritime and Cipriani influences.
Expect fewer rooms but more individually designed suites and waterfront views at Casa Cipriani.
Lotte New York Palace offers a large inventory of room types and multiple suite categories across tower and palace room lines.
Choose Lotte if you need more room options, accessibility choices, or larger suite configurations.
Dining at Casa Cipriani centers on Cipriani cuisine across a few signature venues restricted to guests and members.
Casa Cipriani is for travelers who prioritize Cipriani dining and an elevated, clubby food/drink scene.
Lotte Palace has multiple on‑site outlets for dining, grabbing coffee, and a bar/lounge for drinks.
Pick Lotte if you want variety, formal dining spaces, and easier public access to hotel restaurants.
Casa Cipriani’s pool situation is mixed in sources: historic reporting said no pool, while recent coverage describes a members' rooftop pool.
Pool availability may be limited to club members or be a newer members' facility—check before booking if a pool matters.
Lotte New York Palace’s supplier listing includes a wheelchair‑accessible pool among public amenities.
Lotte offers an explicitly listed pool and fitness facilities as part of its full‑service hotel offering.
Casa Cipriani emphasizes an integrated wellness program and spa experiences that are part of the members' club and hotel.
Choose Casa Cipriani for a curated wellness program and late‑night jazz in a club environment.
Lotte features a full‑service spa, health club and steam room as part of a broad guest amenity set.
Lotte Palace is better if you want a traditional full‑service spa and facilities accessible to a wide guest mix.

Casa Cipriani — members' club spaces, The Restaurant, East Terrace, Jazz Café and Promenade Lounge focused on Cipriani cuisine.

Lotte New York Palace — steps from Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and major Midtown attractions.

Casa Cipriani — extensive landmark event spaces including the Great Hall and Loggia suited for large seated or standing receptions.

Lotte New York Palace — wide variety of room types and accessible room options across palace and tower room categories.
Casa Cipriani is the clear pick — it sits in the Battery Maritime Building with harbor views and immediate access to ferry services.
Lotte New York Palace — it’s in Midtown steps from Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and St. Patrick’s Cathedral.
Both list spa facilities; Lotte’s supplier listing includes a pool, while Casa Cipriani’s pool is reported variably and appears to be a members' rooftop facility—confirm access before booking.
Choose Casa Cipriani for a small, clubby, intimate stay; choose Lotte Palace for a traditional large hotel with many rooms, meeting spaces, and broader services.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·