
Casa Cipriani New York
Best for travellers who want a small, clubby luxury stay with Cipriani dining and landmarked architecture.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Cipriani New York is a members' private club and luxury hotel inside the restored Battery Maritime Building, aimed at travelers who want Italian-club formality and waterfront views. 1 Hotel Central Park is an eco-luxury lifestyle hotel near Central Park for travelers who prioritize sustainability, nature-inspired design, and a central Midtown location.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for travellers who want a small, clubby luxury stay with Cipriani dining and landmarked architecture.

Best for guests who want a larger, sustainability-minded luxury hotel steps from Central Park and Midtown attractions.
When Casa Cipriani New York wins: choose Casa Cipriani if you want a small, highly curated members-club atmosphere, Cipriani restaurants and waterfront terraces, historic Beaux-Arts architecture, and event-friendly spaces.
When 1 Hotel Central Park wins: pick 1 Hotel Central Park if you prefer a bigger hotel with more standard luxury-hotel services, an eco-forward program (recycling, LED lighting, no single-use plastics), and immediate access to Central Park and Midtown attractions.
Bottom line: Casa Cipriani is a boutique, club-forward luxury experience anchored in Lower Manhattan history and Cipriani food and service; 1 Hotel Central Park is a mainstream luxury-lifestyle option whose sustainability credentials and Midtown location suit different priorities and a larger guest capacity.
| Category | Casa Cipriani New York | 1 Hotel Central Park |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Private-members club + small luxury hotel; formal, Italian-club styling | Eco-luxury lifestyle hotel with nature-inspired interiors and sustainable practices |
| Location | Lower Manhattan, Battery Maritime Building; waterfront, near Battery Park & ferries | 1414 Avenue of the Americas, Midtown West; steps from Central Park and Midtown museums |
| Size (rooms) | 47 rooms and suites | 229 guestrooms |
| Age policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must meet minimum check-in age (sources vary 18–21) | All ages welcome (supplier listing: adultsOnly: false) |
| Pools | Rooftop pool reported for the members' club in recent press; earlier sources said none (status varies) | No guest pool listed in supplier facts |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple Cipriani venues: The Restaurant, East Terrace, Promenade Lounge, Jazz Café, Living Room | Jams Cafe plus a coffee shop/cafe; 1 restaurant and 1 bar listed |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Casa Cipriani with sauna, steam room, cedar saunas, cryotherapy, massage; 24-hour key-card fitness | Health/beauty spa nearby; 24-hour fitness facilities listed |
| Known for | Historic Beaux-Arts building, Cipriani dining, private club spaces and event venues | Sustainability measures (recycling, no single-use plastics, plant wall) and Central Park proximity |
| Event space | Extensive event spaces (Great Hall, Loggia, multiple concourses) totaling ~20,000 sq ft | Four meeting rooms listed (smaller-scale meeting/event capability) |
| Connectivity | Complimentary high-speed Wi‑Fi; close to ferries and Lower Manhattan subway lines | |
Casa Cipriani sits in the landmark Battery Maritime Building at Manhattan’s southern tip with immediate access to ferries and waterfront strolls.
Choose Casa Cipriani for historic waterfront access and easy ferry connections.
1 Hotel Central Park places you just off Central Park and close to Midtown cultural highlights.
Pick 1 Hotel Central Park for direct access to Central Park and Midtown attractions.
Casa Cipriani offers 47 rooms and suites with Thierry Despont interiors and many water-facing views.
Casa Cipriani suits travelers who prioritize design detail and a small-hotel atmosphere.
1 Hotel Central Park has 229 guestrooms across standard and suite categories.
1 Hotel Central Park works if you want more conventional room options and availability.
Casa Cipriani’s dining is the property’s core: multiple Cipriani venues serving Italian cuisine and live jazz.
If Cipriani food and multiple in-house dining experiences matter, Casa Cipriani leads.
1 Hotel Central Park’s on-site dining is smaller in scope but sustainably focused.
Choose 1 Hotel for a simpler on-site dining program with sustainability-minded sourcing.
Pool status at Casa Cipriani has varied in reports — recent press describes a members' rooftop pool, earlier sources said none.
Expect club-oriented rooftop amenities; confirm current pool access directly with the hotel.
1 Hotel Central Park highlights sustainability features and a living plant wall rather than pool facilities.
1 Hotel’s signature is its sustainability programming and biophilic design, not a pool.
Casa Cipriani pairs a comprehensive spa program with evening club spaces and live jazz.
Casa Cipriani blends an extensive wellness offering with members’ nightlife and music programming.
1 Hotel Central Park lists 24-hour fitness facilities and nearby spa/beauty options.
1 Hotel suits guests who want straightforward fitness access and easy nightlife/theater access.

Casa Cipriani — small room count, private club spaces and Cipriani dining create a focused, exclusive atmosphere.

1 Hotel Central Park — documented recycling programs, no single-use plastics and other eco measures make sustainability visible.

1 Hotel Central Park — immediate proximity to Central Park, museums and Midtown attractions.

Casa Cipriani — extensive event space (Great Hall, Loggia and concourses) and high-capacity venues.
For Lower Manhattan and ferry-based sightseeing (Statue of Liberty, Governors Island), Casa Cipriani is closer; for Central Park and Midtown museums, choose 1 Hotel Central Park.
Both supplier data list the hotels as not adults-only; Casa Cipriani notes the primary guest must meet a minimum check-in age (sources vary 18–21) so confirm with the property.
1 Hotel Central Park’s supplier listing does not show a guest pool. Casa Cipriani has mixed reporting — recent press describes a members' rooftop pool while earlier listings said none; confirm current access with the hotel.
Casa Cipriani offers multiple Cipriani venues and live-jazz dining; 1 Hotel Central Park has one main restaurant (Jams Cafe) and a cafe, with an emphasis on locally sourced items.
Explore how Casa Cipriani New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·